Week 10 writing workshop exercise

Feedback on: Week 8 in-class writing exercise 

Taylors feedback: 

The structure of this piece is fairly unorganized. The writer starts off talking about a poem, the title of the poem was not mentioned nor was the context of it so it is hard for a reader to understand what the writer is reflecting about. The voice is very curious, the writer seems to have their eyes open and as they are writing constantly just putting down different ideas yet there is no concrete flow to the piece. The tone of the writing is hard to identify as the writer does not seem to have their thoughts very organized and is not conveying one message there are many and it is a lot of jumping around, from nature to happiness surprise and acceptance it is hard to nail one on the head however overall the work is very good. 

Stefs feedback: 

This writer should take some more time to organize their thoughts before writing. The voice in my mind surrounds the idea of happiness, how the writer encounters and experiences happiness in their day to day life. The language is very straight forward. The structure needs some help, the writer does not make it clear what in particular they want to talk about and it makes it hard to follow their thoughts throughout the paper. As a reader it is hard to understand what they are saying, especially because they don’t give context of the poem. In terms of revisions, the writer should read the work through and think what they want the reader to take out of it. The most important part should be brought to the beginning and I think they should give some context to the poem they’re reflecting on as well. 

Leave a Reply